Behavior decides whether a hire works out, but résumés and unstructured interviews are weak at measuring it. Behavioral hiring closes that gap in four steps: turn job knowledge into a behavior profile, assess candidates against the role, run structured interviews built from the results, and use the same data to onboard and coach the new hire.
Ask a manager why a hire didn't work out and you rarely hear about the résumé. You hear "they never took ownership," "they couldn't handle pushback," or "they just weren't a fit." Ask why a star hire worked and the answer sounds the same: how they show up, how they solve problems, how they treat customers. Most leaders already know that behavior makes or breaks performance, even if they never use the word.
The trouble is the assumption that follows. Most companies believe the standard process will surface that information: screen the résumé, hold a few conversational interviews, check references. It doesn't. Unstructured interviews average a validity of .19, and years of experience just .07 (the evidence by method).
Worse, the conversation feels informative even when it isn't. In one study, students interviewed peers and predicted their grades. Some interviewees were secretly answering with a random response system. Interviewers formed impressions just as confidently as they did with real answers, and participants said they would rather have a random interview than none at all (Dana, Dawes & Peterson, 2013). Google's people team names the root of the problem: most interviewers believe they are already good at interviewing and don't need help.
So what does good look like? The methods are not new. Over seventy years, psychologists, militaries and some of the best-run companies have built hiring systems that sample behavior instead of guessing at it. GoodJob, a US-based behavior hiring software company, brings those practices together in one process built around its PATH assessment, developed in response to 1985 Harvard research into the service value chain.
The process is simple, but it has changed as technology and best practice have evolved. One thing has stayed the same: behavior is at the center of how people work and succeed.
In this article we share how the field has done it before, and how you can apply each step on your next hire.
Step one: turn what you know about the job into a behavior profile
Every hiring manager knows more about a role than the job description says. They know which tasks wear people down, which conversations decide whether a quarter goes well, and why the last person in the seat struggled. That knowledge rarely makes it into the process. It stays in the manager's head and leaks out as gut feel in the interview.
GoodJob's process starts by getting it out. In a Role Reality Session, the hiring manager and the people closest to the work describe what the role is actually like: what it must achieve, where it gets hard, and what separates people who thrive in it from people who leave. "Strong communicator" becomes something observable: who this person must persuade, how often, and under what pressure.
That knowledge is translated into a Job Role DNA, a behavioral benchmark for the role written in the same language PATH measures. The team ranks which behaviors matter most together, so the profile reflects a shared view rather than the loudest voice in the room. A Job Role DNA is built once and reused for every future hire into the role. For companies scaling fast or absorbing an acquisition, a CultureDNA does the same job for the organization as a whole.
How the field got here
This is job analysis, and it has a long pedigree. In 1954, psychologist John Flanagan published the critical incident technique, developed from wartime aviation research. Instead of asking experts what a job needs in general, he collected specific accounts of moments when someone did the job notably well or badly. In 1973, David McClelland pushed the idea further by comparing outstanding performers with average ones and studying what the best actually did differently.
Modern practitioners use the same logic. Geoff Smart and Randy Street's Who (2008) has hiring teams write a scorecard of the role's mission, outcomes and competencies before anyone is recruited. The common thread: start from real behavior in the real job, not a wish list.
Where GoodJob takes this further is by connecting behavior to results: analyzing performance metrics, team performance, customer buying behavior and trust preferences, including which people are the most trusted in a company. This methodology has been in use for several decades, but it is widely ignored in favor of vague customer satisfaction or experience data that is rarely tied to employee behavior. The key is to tie preferred customer behavior to specific employee behavior, and use that to further validate the behavior profile standard you hire against.
Try it on your next hire
- Ask the people closest to the role for two stories: a time someone in this seat excelled, and a time someone struggled. Write down what they did, not what they were like.
- Compare your best performer in the role with an average one. Ask what the best one does that the other doesn't.
- Cut the list to the five or six behaviors that matter most, and get the team to agree on their order before the role is posted.
The Job Scorecard Template and Role Definition Checklist walk through this, and How to define the behaviors a role needs covers the method in depth.
Step two: measure candidates against the role, not against each other
PATH is a nine-minute behavioral self-assessment. It measures work-context behaviors: what motivates and demotivates a person, how they approach problems and collaboration, how they think, their habits, and how they prefer to interact and organize their work. Results map to 26 behavioral archetypes across four modes, which combine into 505,914 possible profiles.
What a hiring manager sees is simpler: a green, yellow or red Behavior Match Score showing how closely a candidate's natural way of working aligns with the Job Role DNA. The comparison is always to the role. Candidates are never ranked against each other on charm, pedigree or how much they remind the interviewer of themselves.
Because there is no absolute measure of behavior, GoodJob treats PATH results as a hypothesis, not a verdict, and builds a nuanced understanding of the relationship between a behavior standard and an individual's profile. Every Job Role DNA is different, so a candidate cannot guess which behaviors a role rewards, and whatever the results suggest gets tested in a structured interview built around that candidate's own profile. GoodJob's action research on PATH, gathered from use since 1985, reports correlations of .65 to .75 between behavioral match and on-the-job outcomes. That research points the same way as the academic evidence: the more a process samples real job behavior inside a structure, the better it predicts.
How the field has done it
In 1968, Paul Wernimont and John Campbell drew a distinction that still organizes selection science: signs versus samples. A sign is a general trait a test assumes will show up at work. A sample is a slice of the behavior the job actually requires. The closer a method gets to sampling, the better it predicts.
That distinction is why so many teams get burned by the personality tools they already own. DISC, MBTI and Kolbe are signs. They are valuable for self-awareness and team development, but they describe a person in general, not their fit for a specific job, and MBTI's own publisher advises against using it to select people. We unpack the difference in Behavioral assessments vs. personality tests: what's the difference for hiring?, where we also featured PATH as an example of a behavioral hiring assessment committed to continuous validation and rigorous methodology. Bottom line: a behavioral assessment used well sits closer to a sample. It measures how someone works against a defined role, then gets verified with real examples in the interview.
Try it on your next hire
- Before you use any assessment in hiring, ask three questions. Was it designed for selection? Does it compare candidates to a role benchmark, or only describe them? Does it feed the interview, or replace it?
- Treat any self-report as a lead to follow. For each finalist, write down the two questions their results raise and test them in the interview.
- Expect polished answers. In the AI era, methods that ask candidates to describe themselves degrade far more under pressure than methods that ask for verifiable accounts.
The Behavioral Assessment Selection Guide includes eight questions to put to any assessment vendor.
Step three: a hiring plan that does the hard thinking in advance
The match score tells a team where to look. The structured interview is where they look. Each candidate's PATH results generate interview questions aimed at the specific gaps and natural strengths between that person and the role. Interviewers ask the same core questions, then rank answers against criteria agreed before anyone walked into the room.
This is where hiring managers feel the difference most. Instead of inventing questions the night before and debating impressions afterward, they inherit a plan: what to probe, what a strong answer sounds like, and how to score it. The decisions that used to drain the most energy were made once, together, when the Job Role DNA was built.
The payoff shows up in three ways. Objectivity: candidates are judged on behavior the job requires, which matters most for people whose résumés understate them, such as someone returning from parental leave or someone who started at a community college. Consistency: every interviewer uses the same standard, and structured interviews average a validity of .42 against .19 for unstructured ones (the meta-analytic evidence). Less work: fewer interviews spent on poor-fit candidates, and shorter debriefs because everyone scored against the same scale.
Managers also finish the process knowing more than whether someone fits. They know how the person will work: where they will be energized, where they will need support, and what will frustrate them. That insight is what makes the next step possible.
How the field has done it
In 1955, a 21-year-old Israeli army lieutenant named Daniel Kahneman was asked to fix the army's recruit interviews. He replaced free-flowing conversation with factual questions about six traits, each scored separately. Interviewers were only allowed their overall gut judgment at the end, after the ratings were done. The structured interview predicted far better than the one it replaced, and Kahneman later reported it stayed in use, largely unchanged, for decades.
Google arrived at the same answer half a century later. Its people team uses structured interviewing: the same questions for everyone applying to a role, answers graded on the same scale, and decisions made against qualifications set in advance. Even the candidates notice. Google reports that rejected candidates who had a structured interview were 35% happier with the experience than those who didn't.
The key is building questions based on behavior instead of bias or proxy.
Try it on your next hire
- Write your questions, and what a strong and weak answer sounds like, before the role is posted.
- Score each behavior separately, during or straight after the interview, before you talk to anyone else.
- Hold your overall gut call until the ratings are done. That was Kahneman's rule, and it still works.
- Run the debrief from scores, not stories.
The Behavioral Interview Guide, Question Bank, Interview Scorecard and Hiring Decision Rubric cover each piece.
The best use of behavioral data comes after the offer
Ask most companies what their assessment data is for and they will say selection. GoodJob's answer is that selection is only the second-best use.
By the time an offer goes out, the hiring process has produced a detailed picture: the Job Role DNA, the new hire's PATH profile, and interview evidence showing exactly where the two align and where they don't. Most organizations discard that picture the day the offer is accepted. The manager starts from a blank page and spends three months learning what the hiring team already knew.
GoodJob turns that picture into two practical guides. An onboarding playbook names the strengths to put to work in the first weeks, so early wins build confidence, and the one or two gaps worth working on, with the support each needs. A coaching playbook gives the manager what motivates this person and what drains them, how they prefer to receive feedback, and where development effort will pay off.
The result is a shorter path to competency. That matters because early departures are rarely about the job's technical demands.
The research finds that perceived fit and social acceptance relate to early attrition about twice as strongly as task mastery. Onboarding that addresses how someone works, not just what they need to know, is where the leverage sits.
How the best do it
Google's people analytics team tested a simple intervention. The Sunday before a new hire started, the hiring manager received an email with five actions: discuss roles and responsibilities, pair the new hire with a peer buddy, help them build a network, hold monthly check-ins for six months, and encourage open dialogue. According to Laszlo Bock's Work Rules! (2015), new hires whose managers acted on it became fully effective about 25% faster.
The lesson is not the checklist itself. It is that a short list of specific actions, in the manager's hands at the moment they need it, moves ramp-up more than a generic orientation does. GoodJob's playbooks apply the same principle, with one difference: the list is written for the person, from their profile and the gaps found in hiring.
Try it on your next hire
- On the day the offer is accepted, hand the manager the hiring evidence: the role profile, the scores and the interview notes.
- Pick two strengths to put to work in week one, and no more than two gaps to work on.
- Book the 30, 60 and 90-day reviews before the start date.
- Track how the new hire performs against the profile, and feed what you learn back into the role profile and interview questions for the next search.
The Behavioral Onboarding Alignment Guide and First 90 Days Gap Plan are built for exactly this. Over time, the habit builds skill in managers themselves: each hire teaches them to read behavior more accurately, without depending on an outside expert.
Beyond the hire: connecting behavior to customers and revenue
PATH's origins point to where this goes next. The Harvard service-profit chain research, published in its best-known form in Harvard Business Review in 1994, argued that the way employees work shapes how customers experience a company, and that customer loyalty drives growth and profit.
GoodJob's customer trust and loyalty work tests that chain inside a client's own business. It captures customer sentiment, reviews buying behavior, and connects both to the behavioral profiles of the people customers actually deal with. The question is concrete: which ways of working show up where customers stay, buy more and recommend the company?
The profiles that consistently generate more revenue then become the benchmark for the next hire into that role. The loop closes. Instead of a role profile built on internal opinion alone, the benchmark is shaped by what customers reward. Fairness and consistency are real benefits of behavioral hiring, but the argument that persuades a CFO is that the behaviors you hire for show up on the revenue line.
How it's been done before
The best-known attempt to put numbers on this chain came from Sears in the 1990s. More than 100 senior executives spent three years building an employee-customer-profit model and a measurement system across the company's stores. The model linked employee attitudes to customer impressions to financial results: a 5-unit improvement in employee attitudes drove a 1.3-unit improvement in customer impression, which drove a 0.5% improvement in revenue growth (Rucci, Kirn & Quinn, 1998).
Sears measured how employees felt. The same logic applies with more precision to how employees work, and it becomes far more useful when it feeds back into who gets hired.
Try it in your organization
- Pick one customer-facing role where outcomes are measurable: retention, repeat purchase, satisfaction scores or account growth.
- Rank the people in that role by those customer outcomes, and compare the top quarter with the rest. Look for differences in how they work, not who they are.
- Update the role profile to reflect what customers reward, then hire to it.
The view from the top
GoodJob is led by CEO Neil Pretty, who brings more than 25 years of leadership experience and a background in psychological safety and organizational performance. He is the author of Leading Beyond Fear (Wiley) and a global leader in psychological safety, leadership and adaptability who has worked cross-culturally for the last decade, using behavior science with clients in more than 20 countries on six continents.
That background shows in how he talks about the company's work. For Pretty, hiring is the start of a relationship, not a transaction.
"Most companies spend weeks deciding who to hire, then throw away everything they learned the day the offer is signed," he says. "The real return on understanding behavior shows up in the first six weeks and is very clear in the first ninety days. But it's long after that when the organization can measure how an individual impacted the organization. Results are often the lagging indicator of how people perform. Understanding behavior flips that and makes hiring and people management less of a gamble."
He frames the customer work the same way. "We measure behavior because behavior drives performance. Performance drives trust. Trust is what your culture is actually made of."
And he is direct about the end goal. "We're not trying to make companies dependent on us. We want every hiring manager to get better at seeing how people work, and to keep getting better after we're gone."
Common questions
Doesn't a normal interview show whether someone fits?
Rarely. Unstructured interviews average a validity of .19, and interviewers form confident impressions even from meaningless answers. Structured interviews built around role-specific behaviors roughly double predictive value.
What is the PATH assessment?
PATH is GoodJob's nine-minute behavioral self-assessment. It measures work-context behaviors such as motivation, problem solving, collaboration and work organization, and compares a candidate's results to a Job Role DNA to produce a green, yellow or red Behavior Match Score.
What is a Job Role DNA?
A Job Role DNA is a behavioral benchmark for a specific role at a specific company. It is built from the knowledge of the people closest to the work, usually in a Role Reality Session, and is reused for every future hire into that role.
How is PATH used in the hiring process?
PATH results are compared to the Job Role DNA, then used to generate structured interview questions that probe each candidate's specific gaps and strengths. Interviewers rank answers against criteria agreed in advance.
How does behavioral hiring data help onboarding?
The same role profile, assessment results and interview evidence feed an onboarding playbook and a coaching playbook. Managers start with a clear picture of how the new hire works, which shortens time to competency.
How does behavioral hiring connect to customer loyalty and revenue?
GoodJob's customer trust and loyalty work links customer sentiment and buying behavior to employee behavioral profiles. Profiles associated with higher revenue become the benchmark for future hires.
Who leads GoodJob?
Neil Pretty is the CEO of GoodJob. He is the author of Leading Beyond Fear (Wiley) and a global leader in psychological safety.
References
- Bock, L. (2015). Work Rules! Insights from Inside Google That Will Transform How You Live and Lead. Twelve.
- Dana, J., Dawes, R., & Peterson, N. (2013). Belief in the unstructured interview: The persistence of an illusion. Judgment and Decision Making, 8(5), 512–520.
- Flanagan, J. C. (1954). The critical incident technique. Psychological Bulletin, 51(4), 327–358.
- Google re:Work. Use structured interviewing.
- Heskett, J. L., Jones, T. O., Loveman, G. W., Sasser, W. E., & Schlesinger, L. A. (1994). Putting the service-profit chain to work. Harvard Business Review, 72(2), 164–174.
- Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
- McClelland, D. C. (1973). Testing for competence rather than for "intelligence." American Psychologist, 28(1), 1–14.
- Rucci, A. J., Kirn, S. P., & Quinn, R. T. (1998). The employee-customer-profit chain at Sears. Harvard Business Review, 76(1), 82–97.
- Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M., & Lievens, F. (2022). Revisiting meta-analytic estimates of validity in personnel selection. Journal of Applied Psychology, 107(11), 2040–2068. Summarized in Structured vs. unstructured interviews.
- Smart, G., & Street, R. (2008). Who: The A Method for Hiring. Ballantine Books.
- Wernimont, P. F., & Campbell, J. P. (1968). Signs, samples, and criteria. Journal of Applied Psychology, 52(5), 372–376.
- Does onboarding reduce early turnover? Behavior Hiring research brief.
- GoodJob action research on the PATH assessment, 1985 to present. Practitioner research; not peer-reviewed.
Related
Behavioral assessments vs. personality tests: what's the difference for hiring?
MBTI, DISC and Kolbe describe people. Behavioral assessments predict fit for a specific role. Here is the difference and why it matters for hiring decisions.
How do you define the behaviors a role actually needs?
A practical method for building a behavioral profile of a role before you hire, including who to involve, what to capture and common mistakes.